Menu: Cakes & Cupcakes

Our cakes have a fantastic following! Available for any occasion: birthdays, holidays, events or parties. Baked cakes are almost exclusively three layer rounds (except as noted) and are available in 8" (8-16 sizable slices), 10" (14-28 sizable slices) or 12" (20-40 sizable slices). We can also customize and inscribe your Baked cake. Call us at 718.222.0345 to place your order. Delivery options available.

*All cakes and cupcakes are baked to order and require AT LEAST 48 hours notice. Please allow more time during weekends and holidays. We fill up quickly.*

Cakes & Cupcakes

Aunt Sassy's Pistachio Surprise

Pistachio white cake with vanilla honey buttercream. Topped with toasted pistachios.
8" $39 /10" $50/
12" $69/cups $27/doz

Not Available Online

Available year round

Bananas

Moist layers of banana cake with peanut butter filling. Covered with chocolate buttercream and a chocolate glaze.
8" $49 /10" $60/
12" $79/cups $27/doz

Not Available Online

Available year round

Classic Birthday Cake

Mix & match with either a chocolate or white cake. Top it off with chocolate or vanilla buttercream.
8" $36 /10" $47/
12" $66/cups $27doz

Not Available Online

Available year round

Caramel Apple

Apple cake spiced with classic autumn flavors, then layered & topped with a sweet caramel buttercream. It's like a trip to the county fair!
8" $39 /10" $50/
12" $69/cups $27/doz

Not Available Online

Available in fall

Citrus Passionfruit

New! Orange, lemon & lime zest infused white cake with a passionfruit curd filling and passionfruit buttercream.
8" $39 /10" $50/
12" $69/cups $27/doz

Not Available Online

Available year round

Carrot Cake

Carrots, golden raisins, orange zest, walnuts, ginger, coconut and spices enveloped in a light cream cheese frosting.
8" $43 /10" $54/
12" $73/cups $27/doz

Not Available Online

Available year round

Coconut Cream

White coconut cake layered with coconut cream, topped with a light coconut buttercream and finished with shredded coconut.
8" $39 /10" $50/
12" $69/cups $27/doz

Not Available Online

Available all year

“Coffee” Cake

Chocolate cake layered and topped with coffee buttercream, enrobed with chocolate ganache and decorated with chocolate covered espresso beans.
8" $49 /10" $60/
12" $79/cups $27/doz

Not Available Online

Available year round

Coca-Cola Bundt

Rich, moist chocolate cake infused with Coca-Cola and topped with a chocolaty frosting. It's like you died and went to Alabama!
9" Bundt: $39

Not Available Online

Available year round

Diner Double Dark

In the classic diner style! Devil's food cake layered with a sweet chocolate frosting.
8" $45 /10" $56/
12" $75/cups $27/doz

Not Available Online

Available year round

The Grasshopper

Chocolate cake with a mint ganache filling. Layered and topped with a creme de menthe buttercream.
8" $45 /10" $56/
12" $75/cups $27/doz

Not Available Online

Available in Spring & Summer

Green Tea

A light white cake with almonds and a green tea buttercream. Topped with your very own fortune cookie.
8" $39 /10" $50/
12" $69/cups $27/doz

Not Available Online

Available in Winter

Holiday Spice

Our holiday specialty. Chock full of atumnal spices and frosted with a delicious egg nog buttercream.
8" $39 /10" $50/
12" $69/cups $27/doz

Not Available Online

Available in Fall

Hummingbird

This springtime themed cake has banana, coconut and pineapple layered with cream cheese frosting and topped with vanilla buttercream.
8" $43 /10" $54/
12" $73/cups $27/doz

Not Available Online

Available in Spring

Lemondrop

Lemon scented white cake layered with lemon curd & topped with a vanilla buttercream.
8" $39 /10" $50/
12" $69/cups $27/doz

Not Available Online

Available year round

'Lil Angel Cake

Here’s your Valentine’s Day treat. White cake with a raspberry filling and topped with a white chocolate buttercream.
8" $45 /10" $56/
12" $75/cups $27/doz

Not Available Online

Available February only

'Lil Devil Cake

Get naughty with the 'Lil Devi. Devils food cake with a raspberry filling, topped with chocolate frosting. Pure evil.
8" $47 /10" $58/
12" $77/cups $27/doz

Not Available Online

Available February only

Malted

You gotta try this cake. Fluffy malted flavored white cake layered with milk chocolate whipped ganache. Topped with malt balls!
8" $39 /10" $50/
12" $69/cups $27/doz

Not Available Online

Available year round

Oopsy Daisy

Chocolate layer cake, filled with a peanut butter mousse covered with a peanut butter buttercream.
8" $43 /10" $54/
12" $73/cups $27/doz

Not Available Online

Available year round

Oreo Layer Cake

Dark, delicious chocolate cake layered and topped with a kid-favorite vanilla buttercream and mini oreos!
8" $43 /10" $54/
12" $73/cups $27/doz

Not Available Online

Available year round

Red Hook Red Hot

Red velvet cake with a hint of valrhona cocoa, layered and topped with your choice of vanilla cinnamon buttercream or classic cream cheese frosting.
8" $41 /10" $52/
12" $71/cups $27/doz

Not Available Online

Available year round

Sweet & Salty!

This cake has won many awards and many hearts. Dark chocolate cake infused with a salty caramel, caramel chocolate ganache and topped with fleur de sel.
8" $47 /10" $58/
12" $77/cups $27/doz

Not Available Online

Available year round

Wintermint

Chocolate cake, peppermint chocolate ganache, peppermint vanilla buttercream.
8" $45 /10" $56/
12" $75/cups $27/doz

Not Available Online

Available in Winter

Cupcakes

Cupcake size versions of our signature cakes! Rotating varieties sold individually at the bakery or ordered by the dozen, per flavor.

Not Available Online

Seasonal Varieties Available